What is better, a harness or a collar?

Written by Noa | July 28, 2025

The choice between a harness or a collar for your dog depends on various factors, such as your dog's behavior and size. Both options have their own advantages and are suitable for different situations. In this blog, we explain the differences, the types available, and provide tips to help you make the right choice for your dog.

The Advantages of a Collar

A collar is a classic and versatile tool for dog owners. It’s easy to put on and take off, and you can attach a tag with your dog’s name and contact details. Collars are ideal for dogs accustomed to walking nicely on a leash without pulling.

Types of collars:

Standard collar
Suitable for daily walks and most dogs.
Anti-pull collar
Designed to discourage dogs from pulling without causing discomfort.
Gentle Leader
A head collar that attaches the leash to the dog’s muzzle, giving you more control over the dog’s direction. It gently discourages pulling without putting pressure on the neck.

When to choose a collar?

For dogs that walk well on a leash and don’t pull.
For short walks or when the collar is mainly used for identification.
For dogs without medical issues related to the neck, throat, or airways.

Tip: Make sure the collar fits well: you should be able to fit two fingers between the collar and your dog’s neck.

The Best Collars for Your Dog

The Advantages of a Harness

A harness distributes pressure across the dog’s body instead of just the neck. This makes a harness more comfortable for dogs that pull or are sensitive to neck or respiratory issues. It can also be a better option for dogs with short noses or dogs with back problems.

Types of harnesses:

Y-harness
Comfortable and ergonomic; the strap forms a Y-shape across the chest and doesn’t restrict movement.
H-harness
Has straps that go around the neck and chest, connected by a strap along the back.
Anti-pull harness
Features a front attachment ring on the chest to help reduce pulling.
Step-in harness
Convenient for dogs that find it difficult to have a harness slipped over their head.

When to choose a harness?

For dogs that tend to pull during walks.
For puppies, as a harness helps to protect the neck.
For dogs with breathing problems or a sensitive neck.
For active dogs or during activities such as running or cycling.

Tip: Regularly check that the harness fits well. It should be snug without being too tight, and should not cut into your dog’s skin.

The Best Harnesses for Your Dog

How to Make the Right Choice?

Look at your dog’s behavior.
If your dog walks calmly on a leash, a collar may be sufficient. Does your dog tend to pull or jump? Then consider a harness or an anti-pull collar.
Consider your dog’s health.
Does your dog have medical issues, such as a sensitive neck or breathing problems? Then a harness is often a better choice.
Try different options.
Every harness and collar can fit and feel different. Take your time to see which one fits best and is most comfortable for your dog.

Tips for using collars and harnesses

Regularly check the size. Dogs can grow or gain weight, which changes the fit.
Switch as needed. A collar can be convenient for short walks, while a harness is more suitable for longer, active outings.
Invest in quality. Choose strong, durable materials that don’t wear out quickly.

With the right choice, you ensure your dog can go out comfortably and safely. Whether you choose a collar or a harness, the most important thing is that it suits your dog’s needs and your own walking style.